Mahopac NY Homes for Sale

Mahopac NY Homes for SaleWhether you are looking for a vacation home or your forever home, Mahopac, a growing hamlet in the town of Carmel in Putnam County, is right where you are going to want to be.   Mahopac, located on Route 6 along the Putnam County/Westchester County border, offers a pleasingly wide range of homes and real estate for sale less than 50 miles from NYC.

From lakefront parcels or boat slips on Lake Mahopac, Canopus Island or Kirk Lake for less than $100,000 to beautiful lakefront homes for $1M or more, you will have much from which to choose as you search for homes for sale in Mahopac. 

Jump To: Mahopac Listings | Mahopac Info | Contact Us | Create An Account

Mahopac NY Homes for Sale
April 13, 2024
Avg. DOM
Avg. $ / Sq.Ft.
Med. List Price
40 Properties
Page 1 of 4

About Mahopac, New York Real Estate For Sale

With lakefront lots, single family homes in town, more rural homes, and lakefront homes complete with their own docks and/or boat houses, there is something for everyone in the Mahopac real estate market.

New Construction in Mahopac

Starting in the low $400,000, new construction may still be going on in the Eagle Hill or Random Ridge neighborhoods. Random Ridge is a development of 29 Colonial style homes ranging in price from just under $500,000 to nearly $600,000.

Single Family Homes for Sale in Mahopac

From about $500,000 to just under $1.4 million, you’ll find a fairly large inventory of newer homes in areas like Valley View Estates, Lakeview at Hill Farm.  Home styles are varied and include contemporary, lake house, and Colonial farmhouse among others.  You will find homes in this price range feature anywhere from 2-5 bedrooms and up to six baths, spanning from 1,200 to over 5,700 square feet.  Typical elements include basement, deck, porch, formal rooms, fireplace, interior storage space, and updated interiors.

Mahopac Homes for Sale for under $500,000

While it is true that the majority of homes for sale in Mahopac are priced higher, there are also many homes for sale in Mahopac for under the $500,000 price point.  The above mentioned new construction homes that begin under $500,000 may still be available in Random Ridge. There are several single-family homes, some in turnkey condition, available for sale at any given time, starting around $250,000 in Mahopac.  In neighborhoods like Lake Secor, Maple Hill Estates, and Dogwood Hill, you’ll typically find homes from the mid-20th century and onward. Generally, homes in this range will feature 2-5 bedrooms and up to 3 baths, with floor plans from just under 1,000 to over 3,000 square feet in size.

There are also homes for sale under $250,000 that range from 1 bedroom bungalows with 1 bath,  to 3 bedroom homes with 2 baths.

Co-ops and Condos for Sale in Mahopac

Those desiring a maintenance-free lifestyle will be pleased to find an active condominium and co-op market in Mahopac.  Co-ops start as low as $65,000 for an efficient 600 square feet.  Condos in Mahopac range from approximately $125,000 to $342,000 for a studio or 1-2-bedroom home with up to 3 baths in communities like Society Hill Mahopac and White Sail Condos.  Condo for sale in Mahopac typically span roughly 900 to 1,300 square feet. 

Features may include lake views, sliders to patio or balcony, walk-in closet, hardwood, and separate laundry.  Some condo residences include garage parking and additional storage.  Select complexes include amenities such as gym, pool, clubhouse, playground and tennis or basketball courts.  Many are near daily conveniences and outdoor recreation.

Land for Sale in Mahopac

Land for sale in Mahopac is available for various uses including commercial, property that could be subdivided, lake lots, and boat slips on Lake Mahopac.  Starting at $49,900, opportunities range to $7.5 million.  Tracts vary from .29 to over 18 acres.

Mahopac Recreational Opportunities

Mahopac has several community parks within its borders including Volz and Chamber Parks.  Carmel’s parks and recreation department maintains hamlet parks with facilities for tennis, handball, baseball, football, playground, picnic area with grills, beach, concessions, walking paths, gazebo, fountains and benches.  Additionally, the community offers senior services that include activities and field trips.

Location Benefits of Living in Mahopac

Both Route 6 and Taconic State Parkway, which connect to other thoroughfares, give Mahopac residents access to the conveniences and amenities of the city. The many lakes and outdoor recreational opportunities in Mahopac are a major draw to those searching for homes in Putnam County. Mahopac's golf clubs, hospital, public library, and a myriad of restaurants all add to the reasons Mahopac is a great place to settle in and enjoy.

School Information for Mahopac Students

Students in Mahopac attend Mahopac Central Schools, including three elementary schools, an alternative school, and Mahopac Middle and High Schools.

Back to Listings for Homes for Sale in Mahopac

See all homes for sale in Carmel NY